I hear ya, Norm. I seem to remember a season we finished 19-13, and were invited to the NCAA Tournament (for the first time in many years). Players: (among others) Walter Pitchford, David Rivers, Shavon Shields, Ray Gallegos, Tai Webster, Terran Petteway (highest scorer in the B1G that year), Benny Parker & Leslee Smith. The Pre-season polls for the following year had us in the top 20, or higher.
I remember reading an article (by Derek Peterson, I think), opining we were not going to do nearly as well as the previous year; principal reason the loss of Leslee Smith due to an injury (suffered I think when he played for his National Team). I remember thinking at the time, Peterson shouldn't quit his day job; how could one player make such a difference when we had so many other favorite players returning.
Of course we all know how it turned out; nor does it seem we have had a comparable "Big" since. Could Blaise Keita be 'That Guy?'