Ersty won Gold Gloves as both a center fielder and first baseman. Gordo switched from third base to become the Gold standard of left fielders with 7 Gold Gloves.
Ersty had the much higher ceiling, especially with what he did in 2000. And Gordo had the better small-market career by playing in K.C. his whole career. Both won the World Series, Darin in 2002 & Alex in 2015.
Tough decision as they both excelled at the roles taken on for their respective franchises, in my opinion. Both Ersty & Gordo are highly respected by their ballclubs & fandom.