I will be pleasantly surprised if he ends up being as solid as Tarin was as a freshman. Hope you're right but I don't have a warm and fuzzy feeling about this signing.
Right about what? I don't know much about this kid. I just don't think it would be hard to be as good a player as Smith was. Most permiter Big ten recruits should be better than him IMO.
You say that, but we've brought in Vooch, Hawkins, Fuller, Hammond and Parker, and none of them were particularly impressive as freshmen. I'd say Smith easily flashed more talent than everyone on that list. I really don't think you just snap your fingers and bring in more talented players than Smith. Is it impossible? Of course not. But it's far from a given.EDIT: I noticed you said perimeter recruits. I'm too lazy to change my post, but the point still stands.