Nebraksetballer, the bolded section above is why you got people jumping down your neck. Not the assertion that Atewe is a step down from Agau or other potential targets.
The implication you are making here is he has already been evaluated by ESPN and Rivals, who subsequently did not assign any stars to this particular player, when that is clearly not the case. You exacerbate the situation by going on to say it would be a "waste of a scholarship" and instead need to go after someone the "same caliber of Agau".
I don't think anyone would disagree with you on what you said, per se. It was more in the delivery than anything.